Located where Watertown Plank Road and the train tracks meet in the Village of Tosa.

Firefly provides a lively, cosmopolitan atmosphere and offers an inventive, fresh menu with dining room, bar, fireplace or patio seating.

We’d love to squeeze you in!

Any online booking issues or large parties, please call the restaurant directly at

(414) 431-1444

Food Menu

Our dishes are sprouted from classic roots and created with love, the best ingredients and a playful creativity we hope you will enjoy.

Bar Bites & Shared Plates

Garlic Fries

hand cut fries, garlic gremolata, parmesan, aioli (7) (V/GF)


peppered bacon wrapped boursin & almond filled dates, balsamic glaze (8) (GF)

Three Cheese Arancini

panko crusted asiago, parmesan & mozzarella risotto, lemon aioli (8) (V)

Brussels Sprouts

peppered bacon, parmesan, lemon (9) (GF)

Wild Mushroom Flatbread

roasted garlic, caramelized onion, toasted walnut, blue cheese sauce (12) (V)


white wine garlic sauteed tomatoes, black pepper crostini (11) (V)


Yukon potato crusted calamari, fried jalapeño & carrot, chimichurri (12)

Beef & Blue

seared tenderloin, asparagus, hook's little boy blue cheese, shaved radish, basil oil (13)

Crispy Pork Belly

berkshire pork, ginger, garlic & honey glaze, fresno chili, sauteed kale, cilantro(11) (GF)

Ponzu Chicken Wraps

chicken sauteed with fresh ginger, snap peas, mushrooms, bean sprouts & ponzu, red chimichurri, lettuce (11) (GF)

Microburger Trio

1. white cheddar, bacon chutney, fried onion, pickle, aioli, lettuce 2. wild mushroom cream cheese, caramelized onion jam, chives 3. fresh mozzarella, grilled tomato, basil mayo (15)

Soups & Salads

Chef's Featured Soup


House Salad

mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, onion, parmesan, balsamic vinaigrette (5) (V/GF)

Kale Salad

shaved apple, candied walnuts, togarashi, sesame, sarvecchio, honey lemon vinaigrette (12) (V/GF)


warm heirloom beets, goat cheese mousse, golden raisin puree, toasted fenugreek (10) (V/GF)

Crunch Salad

shaved bok choy & napa cabbage, carrot, wasabi peas, sunflower seeds, sesame onion crisps, chili buttermilk dressing (7 half/12 full) (V)


Pork Chops

jalapeno & parmesan panko crusted pork chops, garlic mashed potatoes, seasonal sauteed vegetables, garlic chili lime sauce (19) (GF)

Chicken Paprikash

pan seared chicken, black pepper spaetzle, caramelized onion, fried brussels sprouts (18)


grilled salmon, quinoa spinach saute, charred grape tomato, goat cheese (24) (GF)

Butternut Squash Risotto

cornmeal crusted shrimp, butternut squash risotto, parmesan, fried sage (23) (GF)

Pasta Pesto

housemade pasta, asparagus, tomato, crimini, spinach, pesto cream, asiago (17) (V)

Pork Ragout Tagliatelle

housemade pasta, pork ragout, rosemary ricotta (19)

Braised Beef Short Ribs

red wine braised short ribs, carrot & sweet potato puree, haricot verts, fried shallot (28) (GF)

Bacon Wrapped Tenderloin

8oz beef tenderloin, sauteed spinach, ancho chili onions, garlic mashed potatoes, crumbled gorgonzola (39)

Firefly Burger

Firefly Burger

organic co-op beef burger, white cheddar, fried jalapeño & onion, lettuce & garlic aioli, brioche bun, hand cut fries (15) (GF bun available upon request)

Friday Fish Fry

Beer Battered Cod

riverwest stein battered cod, house coleslaw and tartar, hand cut fries, served endless (16)


Grilled Asparagus

lemon shallot buerre blanc (5) (V/GF)

Roasted Garlic Whipped Potatoes

(5) (V/GF)

Sauteed Vegetables

(5) (V/GF)

Sweet Treats

Dark Chocolate Cake

warm dark chocolate cake, salted caramel ice cream, toffee brittle, caramel sauce 8 (V)

Baked Apple Blackberry Tart

bourbon creme anglaise, caramel (7) (V)

Crème Brûlée

berries, orange zest (8) (V/GF)

PB&J Smores

housemade peanut butter cookies, chocolate ganache, blackberry jam, marshmallow, tableside flame (9)

Children's Menu

Chicken Strips
Mini Cheeseburgers
Mac & Cheese
Kids Friday Fish Fry

served with fries & fruit

Denotes (GF) Gluten-Free and (V) Vegetarian menu item(s).

A 20% gratuity will be added to parties of 6 or more. When dining or preparing foods at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or egg may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Prices and menu items subject to change at any time. Contact Firefly for the latest offerings.


Our philosophy is simple: to offer a modern twist on classic comfort food and libations with a focus on great, seasonal ingredients, taste and creativity.


What A Peach

bourbon, grilled peach, lemon, cardamom, ginger beer

The Revolver

bulleit bourbon, coffee liqueur, fee brothers aztec chocolate bitters

Rhubarb Sour

barrel raider bourbon, rhubarb simple, angostura bitters, lemon, grapefruit juice


Bitter End

aperol, vodka, brut champagne, egg white, lemon - served up

Mixed Up Mojito

muddled berries, mint & lime with fresh squeezed lime juice & seltzer

Pink Fairy

modest vodka, rosemary honey simple, grapefruit, chartreuse, lemon, grapefruit brulee


They Call Me Bond

ford's gin, modest vodka, lillet blanc, lemon twist - served up

Blackberry Flora

muddled blackberry, almond, vanilla & violet simple, gin, lemon juice, seltzer

Lightning Bug

muddled basil, lemon & sugar, gin, lemon juice, seltzer

House Favorites

Milwaukee Mule

muddled ginger, lime & ginger beer with kinnickinnic whiskey or rehorst vodka

Sinners & Saints

st. germain, cynar, sparkling wine

Tomato Tomahto

tequila, muddled mint, tomato & lime, simple syrup, lime juice, seltzer


Firefly Mojito

white rum, mint, lime, passion fruit puree, lime juice

Dirty Dirty

rehorst vodka or gin with olive brine, dry vermouth and blue cheese stuffed olives - served up

Main Squeeze

malfy limone gin, vermouth, campari, grapefruit

Old Fashioneds

Maple Bourbon

maker's mark bourbon, wisconsin organic maple syrup, bitter truth orange & creole bitters

Black Cherry

brandy, cherry heering, bing cherry, orange & sugar, angostura bitters

Blackberry Balsamic

barrel raider sour mash, blackberry, orange & balsamic shrub, peychaud's, breckenridge bitters


Firefly is pleased to offer three absinthe varieties, all truly unique from one another, with the hope that you will rediscover and enjoy some classic cocktails from a bygone era! All varieties are served with an authentic glass absinthe fountain, chilled water & thin sugar cubes.

Beer, Wine & Spirits

Stop by Firefly for a list of our current, extensive wine and premium spirit selection. We also feature over sixty micro-brews and imports.

A 20% gratuity will be added to parties of 6 or more. Pricing and availability subject to change.

Weekly Specials

Burger Tuesdays

$14 Firefly burger & tap beer

Wine-Not Wednesdays

1/2 Price Bottled Wine

Happy Hour

Monday - Friday 4pm-6:30pm

  • $2 off tap beer
  • $5 house wine
  • $5 select shared plates

Contact Us

Have a question about our menu? Interested in hosting your event at the Firefly?

Kitchen Hours

Monday 4-9pm

Tuesday 4-9pm

Wednesday 4-9pm

Thursday 4-9pm

Friday 4-10pm

Saturday 5-10pm

Sunday - Closed

Bar stays open 1 hour past kitchen closing on Friday and Saturday

Explore our other Restaurant Venue, Catering & Floral Services

Kindred on KK Bay View
Gracious Events